All blog posts
Research 3 min read

Signal, Matrix and MLS: The Messaging Trade-offs We Found

A Secure Net desk review compared private messaging designs and informed session v2, sealed sending and MLS groups, without replacing independent security review.

By Comutability Published Update from
Illustration comparing secure messaging architectures, encrypted conversations, group keys and trade-off analysis.

Research record from 14 November 2026. This article discusses published project research and implementation evidence, not independent certification.

A Secure Net desk review compared private messaging designs and informed session v2, sealed sending and MLS groups, without replacing independent security review.

What the desk review set out to examine

The Secure Net team reviewed its session design against approaches used by Signal and Matrix on 14 November 2026. The aim was to identify concrete deficiencies rather than to claim a universal ranking of messaging applications. The proposal names five areas: handshake binding, stale skipped keys, per-message post-quantum overhead, sender metadata, group recovery and signed-message deniability.

The comparison was made within the project. It is not an independent benchmark, a formal security proof or a reason to claim superiority over a mature, externally reviewed system.

The session design findings

The original protocol included substantial post-quantum key material in each message and did not always expire stored keys for missed messages. SNIP-0006 proposed binding the actual public prekeys into the handshake transcript, hiding more information inside encrypted headers and setting a seven-day lifetime for skipped message keys.

It also proposed spreading post-quantum material across multiple messages. That reduces some traffic overhead but changes the recovery interval after compromise. The notes explicitly acknowledge this trade-off rather than pretending lower bandwidth comes for free.

Sealed sender and message deniability

Even with encrypted content, a relay may learn which accounts exchange messages. The new delivery profile explored sending without a linkable session tag and using delivery tokens to reduce sender visibility. This can limit what sites observe, but it cannot hide every network address or prevent abuse by someone holding a token.

Separately, a signature on every direct message lets a recipient prove its origin to a third party. Removing that signature can improve deniability, but makes some moderation evidence harder to authenticate. The proposal treats these properties as choices with different consequences.

Why MLS entered the group discussion

A group with static sender keys may not recover well after one device has been compromised until every member refreshes their key. Messaging Layer Security, standardised in RFC 9420, provides a structured approach to group membership and evolving key state. Secure Net proposed an MLS-based group profile rather than inventing an unreviewed key tree from scratch.

That does not make the exact hybrid post-quantum ciphersuite mature by default. The proposal documented experimental elements and the need to check libraries, ciphersuite identifiers, membership transitions and group availability. A single designated committer simplifies ordering but becomes an availability constraint when that committer is offline.

Testing and unresolved risks

The change introduced tests and vectors for sessions, delivery and groups. Still missing was qualified human cryptographic review and a formal model for critical transitions. Source compatibility with version 1 does not prove the security of version 2, and real deployments must communicate migration rules.

The research result is a set of engineering trade-offs, not a marketing claim: stronger metadata protection may cost abuse controls, lower overhead may slow recovery, and structured groups may cost availability. These decisions deserve documented scrutiny.

Primary sources and further reading

Explore other Comutability research ยท Read about the organisation

Sources and further reading

Explore the evidence and original project records behind this article.